ME home
 
  SME FaceBook SME Twitter SME LinkedIn RSS Feed

Subscriber or
SME Member Log On

WEB-ONLY CONTENT

Go to SME eNEWS

MINING INDUSTRY EVENTS

2017 George A. Fox Conference  - Conference
Jan 23, 2019
2019 SME Annual Conference & Expo  - Conference
Feb 24, 2019 - Feb 27, 2019
CMA 121st Nat'l Western Mining Conference  - Conference
Feb 24, 2019 - Feb 27, 2019
Fuutre of Mining Australia 2019  - Conference
Mar 25, 2019 - Mar 26, 2019

METAL PRICES


Au
Ag
Pt
Pd
Ni
Cu
Al
Pb

AGGREGATES
AND MINERALS
MARKETPLACE


http://aggregatesmineralsmarketplace.com
The Mining Engineering, SME and NSSGA
Online Buyers Directory Site
The Online Global Mining and Minerals Library Site

Author defends strata mechanics paper published in Mining Engineering
September 1, 2015

Editor:

In response to Mr. Murray’s recent letter to the editor of Mining Engineering (ME, Aug, 25) about my paper concerning barrier pillar mining at the Crandall Canyon Mine (ME, Aug, 2015 pp 21), I was disappointed at the lack of objectivity in his remarks about the paper. Mr. Murray has a wealth of experience in underground coal mining that I respect and admire. However, I doubt that he is a qualified critic of numerical modeling in rock mechanics. In my view, until mistakes are recognized, analyzed and lessons learned, they are likely to be repeated. Hence, it is important to do analyses of strata mechanics, especially of catastrophic, wide area failures. In this regard, my paper presents new, three-dimensional results that are in accord with mine measurements. Those results are neither “old”, “stale” or “theoretical.” I would point out that the paper had been through SME’s peer review process and approved for publication by three respected professionals. The paper concludes with the need to educate engineers using computer programs for ground control to select the right tool for the job. Why is this conclusion objectionable, a “disservice?” I’ll let the readers of ME decide for themselves.

W.G. Pariseau
Emeritus Professor of Mining Engineering
Department of Mining Engineering
University of Utah
 

Related article search: